Officer accidentally shots man in Minnesota

Mike270412

Golden Boy
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
29,394
Reaction score
48,073
Location
GBCA
I would imagine the adrenaline would be pumping pretty heavy in a situation like that.
if they cant tell the difference between the stun gun and the 357mag, yikes! Good thing it was a scum bag and not some old lady with out a mask at costco! lol
 

lilduke

Active VIP Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2009
Messages
19,394
Reaction score
68,919
Location
Local
I would imagine the adrenaline would be pumping pretty heavy in a situation like that.

Are they in the same holster or what? Pretty easy to tell the difference Id imagine. But oh well, sounds like he had it coming.

Im just going by the thread though, I didnt watch the story.
 

snopro

Active VIP Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2009
Messages
108,817
Reaction score
105,777
Location
Milo,Alberta
Are they in the same holster or what? Pretty easy to tell the difference Id imagine. But oh well, sounds like he had it coming.

Im just going by the thread though, I didnt watch the story.
One on the left hip and one on the right Dan. Not sure which side is which but she grabbed the wrong gun.
 

lilduke

Active VIP Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2009
Messages
19,394
Reaction score
68,919
Location
Local
One on the left hip and one on the right Dan. Not sure which side is which but she grabbed the wrong gun.

On purpose, or by accident guess we'll never know. If it was an accident then we're back to "YIKES"
 

Cdnfireman

Active VIP Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2012
Messages
2,726
Reaction score
9,529
Location
Alberta
Kinda thought so, the "say so" and "hear say" muds the water, makes it BS more then proof unless proven otherwise with hardcore FACTS.

BTW hardcore facts is not my friend said so, its in form of documentation specifying so.

Ive been on two police ranges with friends. I personally watched them pull their sidearms out and shoot without racking the slides. And when I’ve asked to see their new guns, they’ve dropped the mag and cleared the live round out of the breech before showing me their pistols. That’s about as hardcore a fact as you can get.
 

Cdnfireman

Active VIP Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2012
Messages
2,726
Reaction score
9,529
Location
Alberta
Yeah she has some splainin' to do

She had to have panicked, or maybe she’d spent most of her time on a desk and just recently went back to the street. Most cops carry their taser differently than the firearms. If you look at the body cam footage of that shooting, you can see the taser of the other cop. It looks like it’s facing forward on his left hip, so not only would he be reaching to the other side of his body, but he’d have to cross draw it. CPS does that in calgary and the RCMP does either that or carry the taser in a thigh carry holster to differentiate, and everywhere the taser is a bright yellow colour. She flat out fu**ed up
 

snopro

Active VIP Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2009
Messages
108,817
Reaction score
105,777
Location
Milo,Alberta
Ive been on two police ranges with friends. I personally watched them pull their sidearms out and shoot without racking the slides. And when I’ve asked to see their new guns, they’ve dropped the mag and cleared the live round out of the breech before showing me their pistols. That’s about as hardcore a fact as you can get.
You are right 100%. Just talked to my RCMP buddy a couple minutes ago. I asked him about it> Here is his response and I would screenshot it if I could post pics on this site. I asked him what RCMP protocols are:

"Fu**ing idiots! Yes you are required to have one chambered at all times when on duty. There is rarely enough time to draw, chamber a round, (which takes 2 hands) and then get on target. So no she wouldn't have chambered a round. I've disciplined officers who were found with an empty chamber. Terrible situation for her. We were trained to either carry your taser on your non gun side or on a leg holster to prevent that from happening. I don't know how she was carrying her taser? Officers learn by muscle memory to draw automatically. I'd draw and unload and load every day. That way you can do it without thinking. I think she just went back to her muscle memory as she keyed her vision on the suspect and accidentally drew on him? The sad part is they try and make it racist. Plus, don't resist and you won't get shot. "

Scott is a good buddy and I trust what he tells me. He was transferred out as detachment chief in Mayerthorpe 2 weeks before that fatal shooting of 4 officers in 2005. He wishes he would have been there but I'm glad he wasn't.
 

FernieHawk

Active VIP Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2008
Messages
1,965
Reaction score
5,563
Location
Fernie, BC
The police chief said they are required to have their sidearm on their dominant hand side and the taser on the other side to help prevent confusion.. If you watch and listen to the body cam video, you can tell she just plain screwed up...definitely wasn't intentional, not a chance.

Concerning the Perp...all of the MSM are showing pictures of him with a toddler on his knee. One news report said he was just getting back in his car when he was shot...you know...just casually getting back into has car after being pulled over for 'Driving While Black' with an illegally placed air freshener hanging from his rear-view mirror. No mention of the out of date plates, his outstanding warrant and his trying to flee from the police while they were trying to handcuff him.

Here is some video the perp posted to social media...looks like a fine upstanding young man.
 

ATV Rancher

Active VIP Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2013
Messages
1,977
Reaction score
7,345
Location
South Dakota
The police chief said they are required to have their sidearm on their dominant hand side and the taser on the other side to help prevent confusion.. If you watch and listen to the body cam video, you can tell she just plain screwed up...definitely wasn't intentional, not a chance.

Concerning the Perp...all of the MSM are showing pictures of him with a toddler on his knee. One news report said he was just getting back in his car when he was shot...you know...just casually getting back into has car after being pulled over for 'Driving While Black' with an illegally placed air freshener hanging from his rear-view mirror. No mention of the out of date plates, his outstanding warrant and his trying to flee from the police while they were trying to handcuff him.

Here is some video the perp posted to social media...looks like a fine upstanding young man.

The welfare state makes a p*ss poor parent. I wonder if this is what LBJ had in mind?
 

Lund

Active VIP Member
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
4,247
Reaction score
11,290
Location
Vernon/Kelowna
You are right 100%. Just talked to my RCMP buddy a couple minutes ago. I asked him about it> Here is his response and I would screenshot it if I could post pics on this site. I asked him what RCMP protocols are:

"Fu**ing idiots! Yes you are required to have one chambered at all times when on duty. There is rarely enough time to draw, chamber a round, (which takes 2 hands) and then get on target. So no she wouldn't have chambered a round. I've disciplined officers who were found with an empty chamber. Terrible situation for her. We were trained to either carry your taser on your non gun side or on a leg holster to prevent that from happening. I don't know how she was carrying her taser? Officers learn by muscle memory to draw automatically. I'd draw and unload and load every day. That way you can do it without thinking. I think she just went back to her muscle memory as she keyed her vision on the suspect and accidentally drew on him? The sad part is they try and make it racist. Plus, don't resist and you won't get shot. "

Scott is a good buddy and I trust what he tells me. He was transferred out as detachment chief in Mayerthorpe 2 weeks before that fatal shooting of 4 officers in 2005. He wishes he would have been there but I'm glad he wasn't.

Well i researched it and in the US they do for sure.
In Canada there are variants, some RCMP carry no firearms. I guess it would depend on their qualifications. The ones that carry are trained to chamber the round and this is more typical in a large city setting.
There has been accidental firing of the sidearm in Canada where the officer is injured and RCMP equipment is damage, it took a while to find info on this for Canada. US info was easy find.
So conclusion in US, yes they do. In Canada depending on department policy, region and so on, they do.

I did have a hard time finding info on this for Canada and RCMP related info., makes me wonder whats the secret while the US info is so clear and easy to find.
 
Last edited:

AkNomad

Active VIP Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2010
Messages
1,550
Reaction score
1,795
Location
Alaska
Just wondering, that 26yr veteran cop that shot that guy.
Claiming it was an accident that she grabbed the wrong weapon.
Wonder how that round got chambered in the side arm, was that by accident too?
No one chambers a round by accident and if cops are driving around with rounds chambered in their side arms we all need to be worried.
So someone must have a smart explanation for that.
Chamdering your side arm is no accident, it’s an act of intent to use.
unless someone can explain.
2 steps are required before a firearm can fire. Step one, chambering, step two pull trigger.
hhhmmm, I smell intent to kill.
Lol.............a gun is basically a hammer without a round in the chamber.
 

snopro

Active VIP Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2009
Messages
108,817
Reaction score
105,777
Location
Milo,Alberta
Well i researched it and in the US they do for sure.
In Canada there are variants, some RCMP carry no firearms. I guess it would depend on their qualifications. The ones that carry are trained to chamber the round and this is more typical in a large city setting.
There has been accidental firing of the sidearm in Canada where the officer is injured and RCMP equipment is damage, it took a while to find info on this for Canada. US info was easy find.
So conclusion in US, yes they do. In Canada depending on department policy, region and so on, they do.

I did have a hard time finding info on this for Canada and RCMP related info., makes me wonder whats the secret while the US info is so clear and easy to find.
I'm just telling you what a staff sargeant from an Alberta detachment told me. Not sure what other regions do. He did say like I mentioned "while on duty" so when off duty or possible doing administrative work they don't? He disciplined officers that didn't follow this protocol so I'm thinking its a hard fast rule in the force.
 

Cdnfireman

Active VIP Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2012
Messages
2,726
Reaction score
9,529
Location
Alberta
Well i researched it and in the US they do for sure.
In Canada there are variants, some RCMP carry no firearms. I guess it would depend on their qualifications. The ones that carry are trained to chamber the round and this is more typical in a large city setting.
There has been accidental firing of the sidearm in Canada where the officer is injured and RCMP equipment is damage, it took a while to find info on this for Canada. US info was easy find.
So conclusion in US, yes they do. In Canada depending on department policy, region and so on, they do.

I did have a hard time finding info on this for Canada and RCMP related info., makes me wonder whats the secret while the US info is so clear and easy to find.

It’s not a secret, they probably think rightly that no one cares or has a problem with it. All cops that work in the public including the military police carry with a round chambered. It’s stupidity to do otherwise.
 
Top Bottom