- Staff
- #21
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2006
- Messages
- 48,082
- Reaction score
- 32,189
- Location
- Edmonton/Sherwood Park
- Website
- www.bumpertobumper.ca
So can one carry a small generator and charge the batteries on the fly? Just curious
Rivian & Ford - the 'Tesla Killer' Electric Truck
- Thread starter Jorg Jorgenson
- Start date
Stompin Tom
Active VIP Member
wouldnt be a small generator.
Thats exactly what a diesel electric locomotive does, but nothing is small or light.
- Staff
- #23
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2006
- Messages
- 48,082
- Reaction score
- 32,189
- Location
- Edmonton/Sherwood Park
- Website
- www.bumpertobumper.ca
so couldn't a 5 or 6000watt generator keep up with a charge in a tesla, for example?
So you have to pay for the power, and can’t charge for it. Plus carry insurance for it too.
Sounds like a deal!
Stg2Suby
Active VIP Member
That's actually a good point for discussion. Yes theoretically you could carry a small generator like a 2000W portable and maybe extend your range by 10km before the main battery is dead. Or pack 2 heavy 7500W generators and gain an extra 75km. Just picking random numbers here but you see where it's going. To get similar range to a diesel powered truck with a large fuel tank you'd be carrying a big enough generator and burning enough generator fuel that there would be no overall advantage.
sirkdev
Active VIP Member
The truck that I saw on discovery channel had regenerative braking attached to the driveline. Not wheel independent. Have to remember that all this energy efficient stuff that you have to haul around with you all day long only functions a portion of the time. Cost benefit longevity all this comes into play.
Cdnfireman
Active VIP Member
Let’s face it. Powering a vehicle using electric motors is a fantastic idea that falls flat almost immediately due to the shortfalls in battery technology. Unless and until a technology is developed that turns some bulk, cheap, easily sourced and environmentally friendly fuel into electrical power, the electric vehicle is a trendy, niche idea that does little more than make its owners poorer but feeling good about themselves.
jhurkot
Active VIP Member
doorfx
Active VIP Member
FernieHawk
Active VIP Member
So I guess they drive only at night as they are charging during the day. Also can’t drive your car the following night if it has been to cloudy/raining/snowing the previous day.
FernieHawk
Active VIP Member
Rivian & Ford - the 'Tesla Killer' Electric Truck
Glad these people feel so good about themselves.
10 years ago I spent hundreds of hours researching off grid power systems for a home I was building on 80 acres in the South Kettle valley. I was forced into this due to the outrageous charges Extortis wanted to supply grid power.
My research was done on Solar, wind and Co-Gen. I learned through research that real life results for residential wind power were much lower than the owners original expectations. Most honest people communicating on wind power forums were less than happy with their real life, in the field results.
Glad these people feel so good about themselves.
10 years ago I spent hundreds of hours researching off grid power systems for a home I was building on 80 acres in the South Kettle valley. I was forced into this due to the outrageous charges Extortis wanted to supply grid power.
My research was done on Solar, wind and Co-Gen. I learned through research that real life results for residential wind power were much lower than the owners original expectations. Most honest people communicating on wind power forums were less than happy with their real life, in the field results.
ABMax24
Active VIP Member
Re: Rivian & Ford - the 'Tesla Killer' Electric Truck
The technology has made huge changes in the last 10 years though. But you are very right that residential wind power systems aren't the solution for most people, they can easily cost 3 times more than a solar system of the same output and still have mechanical parts subject to failure and regular maintenance.
The problem with off-grid is you have to over size the system to produce more power than needed to compensate for less than ideal days and seasons, money that effectively goes to waste because at times much of the energy produced isn't used. Grid tied at this time is more viable as any excess can be sold back to the grid, while allowing to buy back at times of shortage.
The technology has made huge changes in the last 10 years though. But you are very right that residential wind power systems aren't the solution for most people, they can easily cost 3 times more than a solar system of the same output and still have mechanical parts subject to failure and regular maintenance.
The problem with off-grid is you have to over size the system to produce more power than needed to compensate for less than ideal days and seasons, money that effectively goes to waste because at times much of the energy produced isn't used. Grid tied at this time is more viable as any excess can be sold back to the grid, while allowing to buy back at times of shortage.
Cdnfireman
Active VIP Member
Re: Rivian & Ford - the 'Tesla Killer' Electric Truck
kind of a disingenuous statement in bold above. This isn’t “ over sizing” the system, it’s designing it to be a system that will provide a power system reliable and big enough to provide for your needs whenever you need it. That’s what makes a 100% renewable off grid system unrealistic and unaffordable. So people install an off grid system that is enough to make themselves feel good and appear green and trendy to their peers, and then have a diesel generator hidden out back with a big fuel tank for the majority of the time when the renewable system doesn’t do the job.
Oh, and to reduce their carbon footprint by not using fossil fuels for heat, install a couple of wood burning stoves instead. The carbon burnt in the wood is not included in the carbon footprint calculations, because it comes from “clean “ trees and not “dirty” oil, propane or natural gas.
kind of a disingenuous statement in bold above. This isn’t “ over sizing” the system, it’s designing it to be a system that will provide a power system reliable and big enough to provide for your needs whenever you need it. That’s what makes a 100% renewable off grid system unrealistic and unaffordable. So people install an off grid system that is enough to make themselves feel good and appear green and trendy to their peers, and then have a diesel generator hidden out back with a big fuel tank for the majority of the time when the renewable system doesn’t do the job.
Oh, and to reduce their carbon footprint by not using fossil fuels for heat, install a couple of wood burning stoves instead. The carbon burnt in the wood is not included in the carbon footprint calculations, because it comes from “clean “ trees and not “dirty” oil, propane or natural gas.
ABMax24
Active VIP Member
Re: Rivian & Ford - the 'Tesla Killer' Electric Truck
Compared to a grid-tied system it is over-sized, if it was grid tied the excess would be sold back to offset generation elsewhere.
Wood stoves can be considered carbon neutral, when the tree is cut down and burned the tree that grows back in its place re-absorbs the same amount of carbon burnt from the first. Burning carbon based fuels that have been locked away in the earth for millions of years is not carbon neutral, as they would have stayed in the earth for millions more if it were not for human intervention.
Compared to a grid-tied system it is over-sized, if it was grid tied the excess would be sold back to offset generation elsewhere.
Wood stoves can be considered carbon neutral, when the tree is cut down and burned the tree that grows back in its place re-absorbs the same amount of carbon burnt from the first. Burning carbon based fuels that have been locked away in the earth for millions of years is not carbon neutral, as they would have stayed in the earth for millions more if it were not for human intervention.
jhurkot
Active VIP Member
Re: Rivian & Ford - the 'Tesla Killer' Electric Truck
Yeah ok, but can your 1 ton diesel spin itself around like a tank and do 0-60 in 3 seconds ?
Yeah ok, but can your 1 ton diesel spin itself around like a tank and do 0-60 in 3 seconds ?
Cdnfireman
Active VIP Member
Re: Rivian & Ford - the 'Tesla Killer' Electric Truck
No.... but can your Tesla go from a standing start to 60000 feet at mach 1.6 in 2 minutes, track, lock on, fire at and shoot down 4 targets simultaneously like an F22??
just thought I'd ask since we're making unrelated comparisons here......
No.... but can your Tesla go from a standing start to 60000 feet at mach 1.6 in 2 minutes, track, lock on, fire at and shoot down 4 targets simultaneously like an F22??
just thought I'd ask since we're making unrelated comparisons here......
Cdnfireman
Active VIP Member
Re: Rivian & Ford - the 'Tesla Killer' Electric Truck
Thats a pretty big stretch arguing that for carbon neutrality..... so the 60 years it takes for that tree to re-grow we just pretend the carbon added to the atmosphere from burning the tree doesn't exist??? using your argument, Eventually all the carbon being released from burning fossil fuels will be returned to the earth by the trees that absorb the CO2, then die, decompose and become trapped in the earth just like it did millions of years ago....the payback is just a little longer......HOLY CRAP!!! I just solved the climate change problem....(Nobel prize please!!!)
Thats a pretty big stretch arguing that for carbon neutrality..... so the 60 years it takes for that tree to re-grow we just pretend the carbon added to the atmosphere from burning the tree doesn't exist??? using your argument, Eventually all the carbon being released from burning fossil fuels will be returned to the earth by the trees that absorb the CO2, then die, decompose and become trapped in the earth just like it did millions of years ago....the payback is just a little longer......HOLY CRAP!!! I just solved the climate change problem....(Nobel prize please!!!)
ABMax24
Active VIP Member
Re: Rivian & Ford - the 'Tesla Killer' Electric Truck
My example was simplistic in nature to make it easy to follow and not meant to be literal The goal of using wood or other biomass is to have more growing so that plants are actively taking up carbon at the same time it is being released by combustion. i.e. carbon neutrality.
Yes plants will eventually take up the carbon we have released to the atmosphere, it will just take tens of thousands of years.
My example was simplistic in nature to make it easy to follow and not meant to be literal The goal of using wood or other biomass is to have more growing so that plants are actively taking up carbon at the same time it is being released by combustion. i.e. carbon neutrality.
Yes plants will eventually take up the carbon we have released to the atmosphere, it will just take tens of thousands of years.
jhurkot
Active VIP Member
Re: Rivian & Ford - the 'Tesla Killer' Electric Truck
There could be a software update. Never say never.
There could be a software update. Never say never.
Similar threads
